I think there shouldn't be an episode limit for shows that have multiple seasons
That’s fine your welcome to your oppinion. When you make your podcast I’ll happily listen to your oppinion on every show in existance.
Mys145 wrote: I get that you don't want shows like Black Clover or want to focus on new IPs (I rather want you guys used this as an excuse)
I’m being serious do you really get it? It seems like you do not realize just how much time we are investing or you refuse to acknoladge it. Black clover was not dropped due to the 50 episode rule. Andy dropped due to irritation at astra but planned on going back at some point. And I continued into nearly the second season only dropping because of time constraints. But no the 50 epic rule had no baring on it.
Mys145 wrote: but saying that shows with multiple seasons shouldn't count even though they qualify for the year because of past episode counts is wrong.
Again I disagree. I don’t believe there is anything to really discuss. I will not rehash the whole argument. But for clarification of everyone. This is just an fair cutoff point. That is literally 1 year worth of show. This is not a review point if we are still following the show we may still review it. It would be flat unfair to include established epics against new shows your talking top five of nearly any catigory would naturally include the epics if they have anything released that year.
You guys can easily judge the new season of a show as its separate thing without the past ones.
No. No I can’t...
Do you really want a half hearted review of your favorite epic? If I know nothing about one piece would it be fair to disregard it because I watched 12 episodes in season 15. I have no connection to any characters. I literally have no context to anything happening. Yes you expect me to watch season 15 and honestly judge if it’s a better drama then anything on the drama list?
You say I’m wrong and that implies a level of me being unfair. And I wholeheartedly disagree I am being fair making a simple cutoff. To me your being unfair on many different angles.